Everyone has his or her own opinion.
Your recent note to me says, " I can only report honestly on my own experiences but many others in these forums have said the same." OK, I can understand that.
Before that previous notations by you said, " It isn't a painful procedure" and " I think it's important to do so as many first timers look in these forums for advice They post that they have heard bad things and are so terrified that they think they can''t go through with the procedure. Someone could be so scared by what they read here that they could end up not having a diagnostic procedure that could end up saving their life." That second comment "hints" that calling what some regard as pain as only slight "discomfort" helps to prompt some to go through a procedure on a "hopeful" note that it will be OK. I have read a number of blogs that relate very distaste experiences from the procedure itself to the prep to adverse and paradoxical (meaning some people would have a totally opposite reaction to a medication, in the case of versed, meaning instead of being sedated, would become overly excited and perhaps even combative) reactions to versed or other sedatives. NIH studies (National Institute of Health in the US) have clinical studies that quantify that significant numbers of people have suffered pain during colonoscopies. I can understand that painting a rosy picture of this procedure will encourage greater use of this test for first time patients, but that followup visits are severely curtailed because distrust of the medical field results from dismissal of painful experiences.
Stating your personal esperience I DO find genuine, but to say that your experience will mean that someone undergoing the procedure for the first time will have the same experience as you, that is what I interpret as disingenuous.
I have NOT had a colonoscopy, but I did have a sigmoidoscopy, and I was NOT apprehensive at all going in. In fact, I felt exactly as you stated, that "Thousands of these procedures are carried out every day and sedation is optional. If a procedure carried a high probability of pain then endoscopists would insist on sedation and they don't." But after I suffered a great deal of pain, and recall the nurse telling me after a sigmoidoscopy that "You should have been sedated for that procedure," I had my own first hand proof that we all experience pain and discomfort differently.
Because of that experience, I genuinely do NOT trust health care in the US. Health care is reimbursed on a fee-for-service basis in the US, so there is no incentive to really tell the truth about necessity of procedures or the comfort levels of them. The more procedures are done, the more money is made, just just getting patients in and out serves the doctor's financial incentive. Doctors have the financial incentive to do as many procedures as possible, all under the guise of using a risk/benefit model that "knowing more test results" is good, regardless of possible adverse risks to the patients.
Since I have no family history of colon cancer, and none of the other risks of smoking, sedentary lifetstyle, obesity and on, it is my personal choice to take my own chances, which stands at 5%. Since a sigmoidoscopy is a colonoscopy "lite," I refuse to undergo a colonoscopy with my previous first hand experience. I view the colonoscopy as having its place, and is very useful, but with its significant risks, I strongly feel everyone is entitled to make decisions based on their own acceptance of risks and benefits. The medical industrial complex (which consumes 17% of the American GDP, compared to 9.5 - 11.5% of the respective GDPs of other "first world" countries) is constantly stirring up a fear frenzy on commercial TV in the US for every new medication, and every procedure, and I honestly question how much is truly needed, and how much is only out of control capitalism.
So, I also object to being accused of hysteria. I worked in health care for several decades, in addition to having a Masters in Public Health, so I have a a rational basis for my viewpoints. I do not want wish to discourage anyone from having a procedure that they need .... only that everyone be informed appropriately about the which screening tests would be personally appropriate.