Do antidepressants make the depression worse/chronic?

Hello everybody,

I'm on antidepressants now for about 12 years (started with 25 and am 37 now) and i was wondering whether other people might have come to the same conclusion that antidepressant are in fact depressogenic with long term use?

I arrived at this conclusion because when i recall my life before antidepressants i know i've had some tough moments and low mood but never that severe as since i tried coming off the antidepressants. I've had 3 attempts so far in trying to come off and with the first two I've ended up back in the psychiatric hospital due to severe anxiety and suicidal thoughts. Then with the 3rd attempt I weaned myself off slowly from venlafaxine which was hell and 2 months after stopping the anxiety and panic did not go away, feelings of overwhelming and nervous breakdowns came in shorter intervals so i reached out to the emergency psychiatrist who brought me temesta for acute relieve. Then i had to stop working and started sertraline in order to stop panic attacks. Always very shortly after reinstating the drugs I felt better and the symptoms went away. After reviewing lots of studies and papers i arrived at the conclusion that since the drugs inhibit the neurotransmitter reuptake this forces the brain to compensatory effects and this is what makes you worse when you try to come off the drugs and explains why so many people have trouble coming off these if they have been on them for a longer period of time (probably years). Then if they discontinue the AD treatment the doctors say it's either a relapse instead of your brain has not adjusted back to normal yet.

It would be nice to here your stories as it makes me angry and i feel like the pharmaceutical companies or the health-care providers do owe us something in return for the damage they have done with their treatment.

Regards,

D

I don’t beleve that antidepressants make depression worse or chronic.  I just think many psychiatrists are not experienced or informed enough to treat it well enough.  The right psychiatrist makes all the differrence.  

My first episode I was treated with zoloft, was on it for a year, and had no problem getting off.

Second time, 6 years later, I did not do the things that I needed to do to keep the depression in remission and had a relapse, but this time it was mixed depression and required much more work to feel better.

I belive medication helps create new neural pathways to heal the brain, but also feel that therapy does that too.  Your brain is not static, and can heal from many things.  The brain has neuroplasticity,

I belive that if you don’t need the medication, it would be easy to come off of it. If you need it, then it would be difficult.  I have friend who was on Zoloft for 5 years, and came off of it with no problem.  I believe it was because he no longer needed it.  

I wouldn’t underestimate the power of therapy.  It took me 5 therapists to find the right one and is helping me heal.  Therapy can also create new neural patheways.  Your brain is not static.  

How long were you on the medication?  It takes a while for your brain to actually heal from the medication before you come off.  Since this is my second relapse, my doctor wants me on it for at least 2 years when I stabilize.  I may reduce my meds after 2 years, but I don’t know if I will go off completely.  I think my brain needs a little bit.  Anyways, that is just my opinion,

hello greentea,

i totally agree with what you're saying and the latest research does too. i just want the neuroplasticity to work faster ;-)

in 2005 i started with antidepressants, cipralex for about 1.5years and then cymbalta until 2015, switched then to venlafaxine and came off in august 2017. after two month i had to start with sertraline as the panic and anxiety got worse and i felt demoralised a lot because of it. now i stopped working and fell into a depression when i finally had the depression beaten the last year and started to enjoy life again. now it feels like i'm never going to be better and feel kind of hopeless most of the days. the meds have stopped the panic attacks but i still have a baseline of anxiety and the lack of interest or doing anything is bothering me the most at the moment. i question if it is because of the sertraline and whether less would actually be better.

regards,

d

I am so sorry to hear you are having such a difficult time.  The second time I was on setraline again and it stopped working, so worked with my doc for quite some time to find the right cocktail to feel normal.  It takes alot of trial and error and a really good pdoc to get better