Hip/Knee Replacements & Boomers Active Lives

I have been a dancer and exerciser MOST of my adult life, up to about age 61 at which time joints were failing me.....I had a hip replacement at 72. My folks, lived into 90's and were not exercise people and never replaced any joints....true my mother's side of family all dealt with osteoarthritis, but no replacements....

Here is what is taking place NOW:

DETROIT - Orthopedic implants - once the dreaded inevitability of our final, fragile years - are now part of the lives of the nation's active baby boomers and their adult children.

Sure, we're living longer and parts wear out. And collectively, we're carrying around more pounds these days - an increased pounds-per-square-inch grinding down on knees and hips.

But then there's this, too: Few of us - to borrow from poet Dylan Thomas - will go gently into retirement.

Instead, we're zigzagging across tennis courts and knocking out laps at the local pool ...

Twisting and wrenching on hockey rinks and chasing glory on the softball diamond ...

Pounding out 5Ks and marathons trying to squeeze extra mileage out of joints pounded during the era of high impact, no-pain no-gain racquetball and home video aerobics.

All of this means millions of Americans are in line for replacement parts in the coming few years. In the meantime, they turn to everything from physical therapy to pain pills to chicken shots made from the combs of roosters.

Less than a decade ago, 792,449 new hips and knees were put into Americans; by the year 2020, that number is expected to jump to nearly 2.1 million, according to a study published this year in the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery.

"People anticipate being active in retirement," said Dr. James Carpenter, who heads the University of Michigan's new Comprehensive Musculoskeletal Center, where 250 doctors from nearly a dozen specialties are focused on the complex interplay of muscle and tendon and cartilage.

Among baby boomers, he said, "there's an expectation and a demand that they function longer and function without pain."

Finally, today's technology, including fine-detail imaging equipment and robotic arms, have made orthopedic surgery almost routine in recent years. There's less scarring and quicker recovery time.

At the Detroit Medical Center, Dr. Roland Brandt uses MAKOplasty, a robotic arm that helps doctors resurface only the parts of the knee damaged by osteoarthritis. In December, DMC doctors used the machine for the first time in hip surgery, said the longtime orthopedic surgeon.

"The kind of procedure that used to keep someone in the hospital for two or three days with swelling and discomfort is now an outpatient procedure with an hour and a half of recovery time and you go home," Brandt said.

Patients worry about months of painful recovery, but he said: "I can tell them they'll be back on the golf course in two weeks if things go well."

BONE ON BONE

Joint pain is often the result of a lifetime of wear-and-tear of cartilage, the tissue that allows for frictionless, painless motion.

Orthopedic surgeon Dr. James Eberhardt sees it when he pulls out an arthritic hip - the loss of cartilage, the inflammation and then bony spurs that build up painfully as bone grinds bone.

Imagine a chicken bone with that white, shiny stuff at the end, he tells patients.

If you scrape that white stuff off with a knife, he said, "you've given it arthritis."

Such wear-and-tear can be made worse by decades-old, minor damage - the kind of thing that Rebecca Bartek imagines she sees, as if in slow-motion, each time a girl's elbow slams onto the floor of a volleyball court or a knee twists out of whack on a lacrosse field.

For half of her workweek, Bartek is an athletic trainer at Academy of the Sacred Heart in Bloomfield Hills. The other half, she's at Henry Ford Health System's Detroit campus teaching "joint preservation" classes to those in their 30s, 40s and 50s seeking relief from joint pain that has grown intolerable.

"I tell the girls: 'I know you want to get back as soon as you can to playing. But you have to take the time, re-educate the muscles, or I'm going to see you when you're 35,'" she said.

Athletes of any age - both competitive and casual - worry about the right foods to eat before the big game and the best workouts for the gym. They ignore those nagging little pains, often the body's message that worse is to come.

The key is listening to your body's pain now - not tomorrow or next week, she and others said.

"Bigger, faster, stronger - everyone wants that. But you have to protect those joints, too."

Kyle Stack, the mayor of Trenton, knows.

"I was really involved in sports all my life, and I think it's come to bite me in the butt," she said, chuckling.

TOUGH TO EXERCISE

After a lifetime of tennis and ice skating and dancing and softball, she has had both hips replaced and her knee is giving her trouble these days.

Pain - occasional at first and then ever-present - made it tougher to exercise. She gained weight, putting more pressure on the joints, a vicious cycle.

In fact, a single pound is equivalent to 4 pounds on your knee, according to a 2005 study published by the journal Arthritis & Rheumatism. Controlling factors like footwear and gait, researchers concluded that shedding just 10 pounds reduces the "compressive load" on the knees by 48,000 pounds each mile.

"I was getting kind of depressed - 'God, am I ever going to get better?'" she said.

That's when officials from Oakwood Healthcare approached her. Oakwood doctors wanted to partner with the city to step up health screenings and health programming to shrink the city's collective waistline, address chronic health problems and focus residents on healthy living.

Stack was daunted. But - typical of an athlete perhaps, she also was all in.

Amid the clink of weight machines last week, Stack and Roy Vreeland, her personal trainer at the Trenton Athletic Club, reviewed the progress she has made in a few weeks: lifting more weight, more reps, fewer inches and, most important, a general return of her energy and confidence.

"I decided, you know, how can I lead a city to be healthier if I'm not willing to do the work myself?"

On a personal level, she's hoping to delay, even avoid, knee surgery altogether.

In fact, studies have found that remaining physically active in our later years significantly improves musculoskeletal and overall health - even minimizing the overall effects of aging.

Vreeland, counting Stack's reps and with a post-workout tuna fish sandwich and a health drink awaiting, says tracking your progress is as simple or as complicated as you want to make it. Done correctly, though, the results are the same.

"It's the muscular system that supports and stabilizes the skeletal system, including the joints," he said. "When you lose the muscle, you lose the structural support around hips, around the knees, around the back, around the neck, around the shoulders.

"It only gets worse as you continue to lose muscle tissue."

Most makes since; however, done as outpatient with little pain, and back to activities in 2 weeks? Give me a break! Think about it: robot arm...still have to pull out defective joint, hammer in prosthesis, and secure by drilling svrews in place. Bone has more nerve endings than tissue and muscle. Dont believe it.

I also have a difficult time believing this "quick fix"...but all in all the article is a truth on boomers and what we do today to our bodies....

It contradicts itself. First it says joint wear during exercise and sport is responsible for arthritis. Then it says exercise is the key to strong muscles which prevent it. So which is it. I don't believe the story that dance, tennis etc cause arthritis. How come the postman who walks miles in a day carrying a bag of post is not arthritic? There's more to it than that. But is any research being done on this big cause of pain and disability? All the research seems to be in the cancer field. Who gets it and why.

It's a vicious cycle, and I believe because I exercised all my adult life I was stronger going into hip replacement....but I'm one of them who ended up with complications.....

My parents on the other hand did not exercise, dad was in good shape at 96 when he passed and not horrible OA, but my mom had it in her family and she was more bent over and harder to walk at her end years.

Some are lucky to escape OA but I think everyone ends up with some, more than others.....

And as far as postal workers, I'd bet money MANY deal with OA joints....and those living in colder climates even worse off.

We here in So. Cal have had a 5 month horrific heat wave and the last couple days it's broken, and I can feel more chill in my joints...

All our health issues are money makers OA or cancer or the common cold....we have to do our best and that is why I do my own work on Prevention as much as I know how.

Sad to think that movement throughout our lives causes us so much grief later.  Sometimes I wonder what all of these surgeons will do when the babyboomers drop out of society?  And we have generations behind us of primarily sedentary activities...Curious.

 Thanks for sharing this read!

Love,

Dawn

I'm almost sure to say my grandkids will have their issues later in life, they are both very athletic at 15 and 18 and have been doing sports for some years....wish they would have loved the musical instruments more, but they didn't...they were given the opportunity.

I was pretty extreme with my life of exercising, but MANY others more extreme, I was never a runner, thank goodness.....

A friend is telling me about her neighbor guy who is 70+ and doing very well with knee replacement, he was very athletic all his life and even up to the replacement, some times I wonder why he even did it, but I guess he wanted TO DO MORE the rest of his life....those competitive people.

I've NEVER been competitive and did everything I did for ME....and still do...

Living in warmer climate I believe helps with our joint health too....

I think I have lost my vision of me active.  Seems so long ago.  Always an exerciser but not jogging.  Played a great many sports in my youth,  From my twenties on I have been primarily a walker.  I worked out with weights also.  Not extreme.  No one told me what steroids could do to the body, but even if I had known, there were too many times when that debilitating drug saved my life, and helped me be able to work.  I can remember in my early twenties having one knee not be able to bend due to the steroids after being in the hospital receiving huge amounts intraveneously.  I used to joke and say that at least it was always one at a time instead of both at the same time.  Do I regret using the steroids?  Yes, however I simply had no other choice.  I had to be able to breathe.  

I have considered moving to Charleston, SC near the ocean.  But then again I really do enjoy the cold, so British Columbia or the state of Washington tempts me.  I just want to be near the ocean and enjoy the water when it is cold.  Probably from when I lived in Canada as a child beside Lake Ontario where I found solace from my difficult home life.  Not set on any of this quite yet and I realize that as a child I adapted easier to the cold than I can at my current age and beyond.

The colder the climate the harder on the joints...

That is one reason why so many seniors retire in Arizona, New Mexico and the deserts of CA.. and even Nevada which is growing like mad.

I live in So. Cal near the ocean and it's a bit damp but the sun always shines...

Joy, I'm not so sure that it's all down to the heat. I feel that it may be more to do with the sunshine and its effects on the body. The action of sunlight on the skin causes the whole body system to kick in. Hormones, vit D and other feel good factors cause the arthritic symptoms to improve. I found that this effect happened when I lived in southern Spain even in the winter months when it is cold in the mountains but the sun is still strong.