Thoughts on my choice for monofocal IOLs

AI-generated summary

The thread discusses thoughts on choosing monofocal IOLs for cataract patients, focusing on targets and expected outcomes for binocular vision. Key points include patient-specific refractions and biometry (right eye: ~-1.0 to -2.1 D, left eye ~-1.25 to -1.5 D, with consideration of monovision up to about 0.5–1.0 D difference). Participants share experiences with aiming for intermediate/near vision vs distance, and the trade-offs of monovision, with some suggesting left-eye targets like -1.67 D and right-eye -1.39 D as a balanced plan, while others advocate for alternative targets such as -2.01 D left or -1.39 D right depending on reading needs. Several users warn about the risks of under- or over-correcting, halos, and the challenges of achieving precise targets due to individual ocular differences. Personal anecdotes cover outcomes with monofocal IOLs, including good everyday vision, computer work, and near tasks, but also comments about possible adjustments with lasers or overlays. The discussion emphasizes considering age, presbyopia, astigmatism, and whether to pursue toric lenses, with many advising patience and individualized planning, noting variability in surgeon recommendations and the importance of testing potential refractive ranges and the impact on daily activities, especially reading and screen use. A few participants mention vitrectomy-related concerns and floaters complicating decisions, underscoring a broader context of eye health influencing IOL choice and expectations.

I need to finalise the IOL choice for my right eye in a few days and would be grateful for any last input about my choice for both eyes.

My usual glasses prescription is: R: -1.25D, -0.50D x 30°, L: -1.50D, -0.50D x 150°  (+2D reading for 40cm/16&quot and biometry showed:

Left:  Refraction: -1.25 D -0.50 D @ 140°

Right: Refraction: -1.00 D -0.25 D @ 18°  

My current natural lenses give me useful vision without correction.  I can read a phone/tablet (45cm/18&quot, work at home on PC (80cm/32&quot and only need glasses or contacts (multi-focal) when I watch TV or go out.  I would like to be similar to this post IOLs rather than set for distance. 

I have discounted multi-focal or EDOF IOLs based on my experience with multi-focal contacts as they're all a compromise and my preference is sharpest vision even if some ranges need glasses/contacts.  

The Tecnis mono focal appears a good choice and target options for me are:

Left:  -2.01, -1.67, -1.33, -0.99, -0.65, -0.32,  0.00

Right: -2.08, -1.74, -1.39, -1.06, -0.72, -0.39, -0.06

I appreciate the variation in results, but it still makes sense to consider the targets carefully, and I'll re-consider the left eye target once the right is settled. 

Trying to allow for loss of current accommodation (I estimate 0.5D) and a reduction of astigmatism due to the incision location, I am considering: 

Left: -1.67D, Right (dominant): -1.39D

I know some surgeons say -1D and -2D is good but that's too much monovision for my liking (0.5D max for me). I've read comments saying -1D gives good intermediate and some close, others saying -1.5D to -2D is needed, so I would be grateful on any input from people with monofocals set for intermediate or close.

Are you having lens replacement due to cataracts that have deteriorated your vision to 20/50 at least making driving difficult.  As you didn’t mention - thought I would strongly advise you against this procedure unless it is due to cataracts.  Many greedy doctors are now pushing this procedure as a way to get rid of glasses and never advise about the complications or that it isn’t an exact science where your prescription can be targeted with exact precision and even with monofocals there can be halos blurred vision and other complications.

Don’t want to unnecessarily frighten you but want you to seriously reconsider this procedure if you don’t have cataracts impeding your vision.  Nothing is as good as your natural lens and you will notice vast differences between what you see with your natural eye vs an IOL.  All of us with advanced cataracts don’t recall what our natural vision was like so we see a huge improvement with this surgery.

My apologies if you do have cataracts and I wish you a successful outcome.

There just seems to be a lot of people coming on these forums with complications and problems that opted for cataract surgery to off their glasses.

I think that if you end up with your choice of (and actually achieve) "Left: -1.67D, Right (dominant): -1.39D", you may have trouble reading the fine print on the phone / tablet / book at 18 inches, while you should be fine with working on PC at 32 inches.

My suggestion will be stay with your choice of -1.39 D for the right eye, but seriously consider aiming for -2.01D for the left eye. That will provide you much better vision for your requirements. Most people don't even notice a difference of 0.6D between the two eyes. (you are already used to half of that difference). That will be a very good choice for you.

Sounds nearly identical to my situation. At 10 weeks post-op Right eye with Alcon AcrySof IQ monofocal (non-toric) IOL I am -1.25D(0 Cyl); with Left eye (small asymptomatic cataract) at  -1.5D (-0.25Cyl).  So far I am thrilled with the result, as it affords great everyday vision without refraction a good deal of the time; computer is excellent and near/reading is very good.  I haven't had to use readers yet at all.  I wear mostly Rx sunglasses for outdoor daytime (driving, hiking, biking, etc.) and either regular glasses or a single contact (monovision) for evening driving or socializing.  I've been experimenting with a couple of different contacts in the Left eye and so far it seems that a similar result for the Left (-1 to -1.5) would be ideal, when the time comes, but I could tolerate up to maybe a -0.75 asymmetry.

I went out for an evening last week with a left contact resulting in -0.25 L / -1.25 R and it was great for distance and short-term near (checking my phone; reading a menu), but terrible for longer-term computer and reading so I was happy to have the option of removing the left contact at the end of the evening vs. being permanently that way.  

You don't mention your age (I am 58), but that is key, I think.  If you are well into presbyopia then it's probably easier to predict the outcome. If on the younger side, the cautious recommendation (-1.5 to -2) is a safer choice to preserve good reading.   As I understand, this is not an exact science and individual results vary. You don't mention how much time you anticipate between surgeries, but I should also mention that between 2 and 6 weeks my vision changed a bit (-1 to -1.25) just FYI.

Best of luck with your surgery!

 

Your calculations are excellent.

From my experience with a monofocal Tecnis lens in my right eye set for good distance, it ended up I estimate near the target of -0.25D.

I find with that eye I need at least 1.25D reading glasses for good smartphone focus, but thats with my arm extended out nearly as far as it will go about 24".  So for more comfortable viewing 1.50D glasses work better.

For computer monitor distance viewing which is a little farther, up to 36", I find 1.0D works fine.

So to get what it sounds like you are used to now, a target of near -1.5D would seem to be close. But remember there is always about a 0.5D error possible due to the steps the IOL is available in and even more possible error from how individual corneas heal.  Its not an exact science unfortunately.

I don't have cataracts but am not looking to avoid glasses/contacts.  I suffer from severe vitreous floaters and have done so for several years. They impact my work and far too numerous and large for neural adaptation to make any significant difference. In fact I think my brain has attempted to ignore so much visually that I miss many details in daily life as my mind just assumes movement is floaters zooming by.

This leaves me with little choice but a vitrectomy despite the risks, and at 51 with a history of inflammatory conditions its expected that I'll have less than 2 years before cataract and such cataracts progress far more rapidly than most age related ones.  As the cataract procedure and potential PCO lasering can cause floaters especially in those that had them in the main vitreous I have had a couple of surgeons suggest combined floater vitrectomy and IOL. This also allows more thorough vitrectomy and reduced risk of further floaters. 

I am loathe to lose my natural lenses for the reasons you state but then living the rest of my life looking through more floating debris than I can possibly count (even with eyes shut in the day/lit room) isn't a great life either. I also don't know if I have the mental reserve for surgery for vitrectomies then cataracts and possible PCO for each eye on top of a number of other long term medical conditions I have to deal with.

I didn't mention the reason for the IOLs initially as I know many people consider vitrectomy surgery for floaters wrong, as indeed I would, if I only had a few. 

Thanks for your thoughts, and yes one of my plans is to increase closeness of the left eye if needed depending on how the right goes. My contact lens tests show 0.5D difference is not enough to increase eye strain for me, whereas a 1D difference although great for general vision, did cause strain when working at a fixed distance such as the PC. 

As targets are not precise starting with a -1.39D for the right dominant eye seems a good plan as if I am lucky and within +/- 0.25D (or a bit more) then either is workable.  If I started with -1.06D or -1.76D the margin for error could take it further away.  My left eye also has the most astigmatism (0.6D before rounding) and it will be interesting to see if the incision and lens change reduces this for the right eye first as the current left eye astigmatism helps close reading.  I am not opting for toric lenses as my level of astigmatism isn't that high and I want to avoid the rotation problem.

Ultimately I can have a laser tweak or secondary lens but hoping to avoid if possible.

It sounds like you have researched and are aware and weighed the risks and benefits of lens replacement.  So sorry you’ve had a difficult history with your vision.  I sincerely wish you a successful outcome.  

There have bee a few who’ve opted for lens replacement far younger than yourself and not been made aware of any of the potential risks and shortcomings of cataract surgery.  I had cataract surgery a few short months ago at 53. My cataracts developed and progressed so rapidly (within 8 months of my last optometrist appointment where all checked out fine. )

good luck with your surgery.

That is a very good idea of starting with -1.39 D for the right dominant eye and see what you actually end up. Knowing exactly what you end up for the right eye (and the vision should be stabilized enough in about a month for you to know that) will put you in a much better position to decide on the best target prescription for the left eye.

With best wishes for a very successful surgery.

Thanks for the all the info. 

The slight astigmatism in your left eye will also add to its close range ability.

I am 51 and presbyopia became an issue in my late 30s so it looks like I am on the path down to as little as 0.5D accommodation with my natural lenses. I already need +2.5D  to +3D for very close work (12&quot  so I think I am nearly down to that.

I think of my eye prescription as myopia plus half the astigmatism as the average, so for me that's about another -0.25D on top for each eye.   Allowing for this astigmatism and accommodation my vision fits very well with expectation so at least I know what seems to work now - just hope I can get somewhere near post IOL.

Due to the reason for my surgeries (see post above) and history of inflammatory conditions I've been advised to leave 8 weeks between so hopefully the eye sight will have settled by then.

What's wrong with left -2.01/right -2.08 combination or left -1.67/right -1.74 combination? Good distance vision if you wear contacts/glasses and little to no monovision. You just need to move objects a little away from you to see close up.  

So sorry to hear about having to deal with the floaters, vitrectomy etc. in addition to the lens replacement.  Sounds like you've really put a lot of careful thought and research into this. Interestingly, I also opted for a -1.39D lens calculation for my dominant eye, but didn't have nearly as much information at that time as you seem to have. Wishing you all the best for your procedure and recovery.

There's nothing wrong either and starting with the right eye targeting -1.74D would be my second choice and then decide the left based on the result.  It's mainly the varying opinions that have made me consider this so much. Even two ophthalmic surgeons in the same practice suggested quite different powers (0.75D target difference) for what I asked, one claiming its always better than expected. One was early 30s though so I expect doesn't appreciate the impact of loss of reading distance as the other mid 50s surgeon does.

Ultimately I am probably over thinking the numbers (software developer trait) as I even have a spreadsheet with defocus curves of various IOLs with adjustable offset. There are just too many variables though but at least I can feel confident I've been thorough no matter what the outcome.

I'm looking to implant two monofocal lenses in the similar lens power range as yours after cataract surgery. So this thread is quite helpful, thanks for posting. It's nice to have someone doing the overthinking part for me...ha.

I also need to finalize the lens choice next Tue when I see my surgeon who was intrigued by the choice of lens power range. This is a very reputable eye doctor saying to me that I'm the first patient in her >30yrs of practice who chooses not to have 20/20 distance vision after surgery! You and I are the rare breed...

My current choice(which could likely change after next Tue) is: set my dominant eye between -1.5D and -2.0D and then the other eye a little less myopic but no more than 0.5D different between the two. That way, it's a matter of moving objects either a little in or a little out to get the best focus. I also feel that the lens power difference of 1.0D between two eyes causes eye strain which I may or may not be able to get used to.

I find it interesting the surgeons haven’t had a lot of requests for intermediate/ near vision vs 20/20 for distance.  Lille #1 reason I opted for Symfony lenses.  Didn’t realize they could or would with monofocal IOLs.  I really think one appreciates being able to read vs wearing glasses for distance.  Why is that such a rare request?

That is a good question. My guess is most patients who value near vision choose multifocal or EDOF lenses... so much allure for 20/20 distance vision? I don't know. My current surgeon is not a big fan of multifocals and seems open to my choice of lens power, which was not the case for the first two surgeons I encountered.

You are likely right.  Although still think in best interest of patient (not to mention patient budget) this should be an option discussed.  Not everyone can or wants to pay for multifocal or EDOF lenses.

I think its simply if a patient doesn't know to ask about more monofocal IOL options it's not in a surgeons interest to offer choices that may cause a patient difficulty in deciding or could lead to higher expectations.and therefore lower satisfaction with the result. Many people don't know how focusing works and changes with age so that's another hurdle to overcome when discussing a compromise solution.  

Up-selling so called premium lenses provides financial benefit for many surgeons and its easier to describe to patients so that's worth their time.

I've wondered that, too, Sue.An.  From my observation, it seems that the patients interested in this option (myself included) already have mild myopia, and really like being able to read without glasses after presbyopia sets in; therefore want to stay that way.  I suspect doctors are especially hesitant to venture too much into the 'intermediate' range for fear the patient will be unhappy if they end up requiring glasses for both very far and very near.  It's probably a much safer bet to opt for something more predictable ("you'll see far, but need readers&quot. Just my theory, anyway.

Yes do agree.  I reckon my thoughts are post operation and feel there is so little info - and lots of misinformation too.  In my ideal world a person would be better informed before surgery- particularly if they are younger and still working full time.  Just having breakfast after going to clinic for blood tests.  Nurse made a comment about not being able to read my form and progressive glasses not working so well and she’s considering clear lens exchange although her husband had cataract surgery and she said his near vision is worse than hers. I did tell her to read up on CLE as she  could end up in a worse place than needing glasses. I really think doctors are motivated by money and not what is best for patient.  

I am most puzzled why some people with regular monofocal lenses set for distance do get a range of vision.  Do you think that has to do with eye’s natural accommodation?  Type of lens?   There are so many variables and likely doctors cannot pinpoint where you end up with so easier not to have the conversation.  Back to square one - lol.  And the ones that do research - those patients the doctor doesn’t want.  Too picky.